Charlton Athletic (2–3–5): Willie Duff – Trevor Edwards, Don Townsend – John Hewie, Derek Ufton, Billy Kiernan – Ron White, Fred Lucas, Johnny "Buck" Ryan, Stuart Leary, Johnny Summers Huddersfield Town (2–3–5): Sandy Kennon – Tony Conwell, Ray Wilson – Ken Taylor, Jack Connor, Bill McGarry – Bob Ledger, Stan Howard, Alex Bain, Les Massie, Ron Simpson (Howard played for Huddersfield instead of their rising star, 17-year-old Denis Law, who was rested due to a thigh injury) Derek Ufton was taken to hospital after 17 minutes with a dislocated shoulder.