Plymouth: Larrieu, Sawyer, Barker, Judge, Mackie, Summerfield (McNamee, 73 ) , Clark, Fletcher, Duguid, Arnason, Fallon Subs not used: Folly,Gow,Barnes,Saxton,Joe Mason, Newcastle: Krul, Ryan Taylor, Simpson, Kadar, Coloccini, Pancrate ( Lovenkrands, 79 ) , Butt, Guthrie, Ranger ( Carroll, 68 ) , Ameobi, Smith ( Gutierrez, 71 ) Subs not used: Harper, Enrique, Tozer, Donaldson, Bookings: Arnason , Duguid , Fallon (Plymouth) Ranger , Ryan Taylor (Newcastle) Attendance: 16451 Referee: A G Wiley (Staffordshire)