Card 1
Bert Trautmann
Manchester City
Card 2
Alf Stokes
Tottenham Hotspur
Card 3
Brian Clough
Middlesbrough
Card 4
Jackie Milburn
Newcastle United
Card 5
Duncan Edwards
Manchester United
Card 6
Roger Byrne
Manchester United
Card 7
Ray Daniel
Sunderland
Card 8
Ronnie Allen
West Bromwich Albion
Card 9
Reg Matthews
Chelsea
Card 10
Ivor Allchurch
Swansea City
Card 11
Tony Marchi
Tottenham Hotspur
Card 12
Dennis Viollet
Manchester United
Card 13
Ron Reynolds
Tottenham Hotspur
Card 14
Tom Finney
Preston North End
Card 15
Jack Kelsey
Arsenal
Card 16
Tommy Taylor
Manchester United
Card 17
George Young
Rangers
Card 18
Roy Bentley
Fulham
Card 19
Stanley Matthews
Blackpool
Card 20
Len Shackleton
Sunderland
Card 21
Lawrie Reilly
Hibernian
Card 22
Derek Tapscott
Arsenal
Card 23
Johnny Haynes
Fulham
Card 24
Billy Liddell
Liverpool