Card 1
Wilf Mannion
Middlesbrough
Card 2
Stanley Matthews
Blackpool
Card 3
Bill Holden
Burnley
Card 4
Ted Ditchburn
Tottenham Hotspur
Card 5
Bert Trautmann
Manchester City
Card 6
Joe Mercer
Arsenal
Card 7
Derek Dooley
Sheffield Wednesday
Card 8
Trevor Ford
Sunderland
Card 9
Tom Finney
Preston North End
Card 10
Billy Liddell
Liverpool
Card 11
Peter Doherty
Doncaster Rovers
Card 12
Johnny Hancocks
Wolverhampton Wanderers
Card 13
Jackie Sewell
Sheffield Wednesday
Card 14
Jimmy Logie
Arsenal
Card 15
Johnny Carey
Blackburn Rovers
Card 16
Alf Ringstead
Sheffield United
Card 17
George Robledo
Colo-Colo
Card 18
Nat Lofthouse
Bolton Wanderers
Card 19
Alf Ramsey
Tottenham Hotspur
Card 20
Bill Eckersley
Blackburn Rovers
Card 21
Eddie Quigley
Blackburn Rovers
Card 22
Charlie Mitten
Fulham
Card 23
Roy Paul
Manchester City
Card 24
Ray Lambert
Liverpool
Card 25
Jack Rowley
Manchester United
Card 26
Ivor Broadis
Manchester City
Card 27
Ted Burgin
Sheffield United
Card 28
Henry Cockburn
Manchester United
Card 29
Albert Quixall
Sheffield Wednesday
Card 30
Jackie Milburn
Newcastle United
Card 31
Len Duquemin
Tottenham Hotspur