Card 1
Norman Sykes
Bristol Rovers
Card 2
Joe Hayes
Manchester City
Card 3
Ray Pointer
Burnley
Card 4
Wally Bellett
Plymouth Argyle
Card 5
Stanley Matthews
Blackpool
Card 6
Billy Liddell
Liverpool
Card 7
Jackie Henderson
Arsenal
Card 8
Tim Coleman
Stoke City
Card 9
Nat Lofthouse
Bolton Wanderers
Card 10
Don Revie
Leeds United
Card 11
Denis Law
Huddersfield Town
Card 12
Peter McParland
Aston Villa
Card 13
Trevor Smith
Birmingham City
Card 14
Tommy Banks
Bolton Wanderers
Card 15
David Herd
Arsenal
Card 16
Jeff Whitefoot
Nottingham Forest
Card 17
Peter Broadbent
Wolverhampton Wanderers
Card 18
Derek Hogg
West Bromwich Albion
Card 19
Harry Gregg
Manchester United
Card 20
Ivor Allchurch
Newcastle United
Card 21
Bobby Collins
Everton
Card 22
Danny Malloy
Cardiff City
Card 23
Bobby Charlton
Manchester United
Card 24
Larry Carberry
Ipswich Town
Card 25
Tom Finney
Preston North End
Card 26
Terry Bly
Norwich City
Card 27
Arthur Kaye
Blackpool
Card 28
Glen Wilson
Brighton & Hove Albion
Card 29
Colin McDonald
Burnley
Card 30
Phil Woosnam
West Ham United
Card 31
Len White
Newcastle United
Card 32
Joe Shaw
Sheffield United
Card 33
Tommy Docherty
Arsenal
Card 34
Gordon Smith
Hibernian
Card 35
Ray Charnley
Blackpool
Card 36
Bob Morton
Luton Town
Card 37
Terry Medwin
Tottenham Hotspur
Card 38
Billy Wright
Wolverhampton Wanderers
Card 39
Albert Quixall
Manchester United
Card 40
Roy Gratrix
Blackpool
Card 41
Dennis Viollet
Manchester United
Card 42
Derek Mayers
Preston North End
Card 43
Bill Perry
Blackpool
Card 44
Ron Flowers
Wolverhampton Wanderers
Card 45
John Atyeo
Bristol City
Card 46
Graham Shaw
Sheffield United
Card 47
Willie Fernie
Middlesbrough
Card 48
Mel Charles
Arsenal