Card 1
Billy Wright
Wolverhampton Wanderers
Card 2
Jimmy Greaves
Tottenham Hotspur
Card 3
Denis Law
Manchester United
Card 4
Bert Trautmann
Manchester City
Card 5
Billy Bingham
Sunderland
Card 6
Tom Finney
Preston North End
Card 7
Bobby Moore
West Ham United
Card 8
Jack Charlton
Leeds United
Card 9
Nat Lofthouse
Bolton Wanderers
Card 10
John Charles
Leeds United
Card 11
Gordon Banks
Leicester City
Card 12
Stanley Matthews
Blackpool
Card 13
Jimmy Armfield
Blackpool
Card 14
Danny Blanchflower
Tottenham Hotspur
Card 15
Ian St John
Liverpool
Card 16
Johnny Haynes
Fulham
Card 17
Stan Mortensen
Blackpool
Card 18
Billy Liddell
Liverpool
Card 19
Jackie Milburn
Newcastle United
Card 20
George Cohen
Fulham
Card 21
Duncan Edwards
Manchester United
Card 22
Jim Baxter
Rangers
Card 23
Bobby Charlton
Manchester United
Card 24
George Best
Manchester United